http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/StockInvestingTrading/canprepschoolmakeyourich_serieshome.aspx
This is an article about whether or not attending a fancy prep school gives you an edge when it comes to the real world. I found this story pretty interesting, but it seemed to be missing a few key points. The author concluded that education can definitely influence the future and behaviors of its students, which there’s no doubt is true, but aren’t there other factors at work here?
This story mainly deals with a few of the best, most expensive schools in the country. One of them estimates that 10% of its alumni are worth $15 million or more. But let’s just think about this for a second. There are two types of students who attend these schools. The first are from wealth families that can afford $40K tuition. These kids generally either walk right into family money as adults, or are given a high up position at a family company. The others are the genius scholarship kids. The kids that could pretty much do anything they want, right? Therefore is it really necessary to go to a school such as this?
So what do you guys think? How much does education influence your human capital and therefore your productivity and revenue? In other words, if you’re smart enough to get into a school like this, do you need to go? Or is it a waste of money, and you can do just fine for yourself anyway?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I personally am not a huge advocate of these uber-expensive prep schools. I very much agree with your points about who can afford to go to them and the fact that those kids really don't need any help getting ahead in this world as it is.
Colleges may look more favorably upon accepting students from such prestigious schools, just as employers may look more favorably upon students who graduate from more prestigious colleges. But a huge majority of the ones who can afford to do so already have their futures pretty much laid at their feet.
Education does matter, though, and I wish that a great deal more focus could be placed upon those schools whose funding is virtually nonexistent and whose dropout rates are over 50%. But because those kids' parents can't pay, the kids are forced to.
It's a shame. The better one's education, the better one's opportunities, but only to a certain extent. After a while, no matter how good one's schooling is, one is still going to reach some sort of limit. Too bad the focus therefore can't be on those lacking opportunities altogether.
Its that problem with statistics. They lie.
These prep kids are successful because they go the the prep school or because daddy owns the hummer company?
They are taking association and implying causation.
Can you tell I was just studying for the stats exam? sorry...
Employers look much less at fancy schools than you'd think. Even when you're becoming a doctor or lawyer (although in a place like, say, NYC, it will probably count more).
Love the stats correlation, Melody! :)
Education does increase your human capital, obviously, but like you said a good chunk of the kids going to these schools are from wealthy families and are in line to work at their parents businesses when they are out of school.
These schools may, or may not, be a waste of money, depending on what your reasons for going are. If you think the school specializes in specific programs you're interested in and has a vibe that you like then maybe it is worth it. but for name recognition alone? heck no.
I think that going to college is the right thing to do for a lot of people, but i think that you can not go to college and be successful as well. and why should you go to college and spend tons of money if the thing you want to pursue doesn't require college education? i guess to increase your human capital a little and to increase your knowledge on things...
Wow Lydia, it's a combination of Stats and Econ, congrats. Anyway, I personally think that these confounding variables do affect the statistics of the classes of the "genius prep schools". Yes, the bulk of the student population at these schools are either child of priveledge or genius'. However, the connections and networking you can do at these school may be a real advantage.
I think that having the extra eduation does increase your human capital. I have a big problem with kids that go just because they can, especially if they're not deserving of it. Those that get in through scholarships, however, definitely deserve the chance to go. These schools are extremely expensive, but a lot of that has to do with the fact that many of them offer a level of education that isn't available in public schools. The kids that have the ability to handle that caliber of learning should be able to, otherwise they'll just get bored in public schools and won't reach their full potential.
Post a Comment