Sunday, April 6, 2008

Britney Spears and Hannah Montana (my heroes!)

I was reading Time this morning when i noticed they were taking a poll online in order to determine the top 100 most influential people. Sounds simple enough, the people who most influence our lives, i.e. politicians, world leaders and such should come out on top right?

Wrong. As of the time i'm writing this, Britney Spears is currently ranked third, right above Madonna and Perez Hilton. Oprah Winfrey and Warren Buffett are right up there as well, just before David Beckham, Will Smith and Matt Damon.

To me, this is said. But, it just goes to prove what we've been saying all along, that people vote with their pocket book. These people certainly influence a lot of economic decisions, such as which brand will i buy, what movie to go see and what shoes to wear and even rack up billions of dollars in ad revenue while people click around the net trying to figure out what's new with Britney. But do any of these things really matter? No. I know this is really more of a rant than an econ analysis, but if you ask me it's time people stop thinking that money makes the world go round and try to do something worthwhile with their life.

I was, however, glad to see Barack at 7 and Hilary at 8.

Oh and by the way, Miley Cyrus is currently narrowly beating out George W. Bush.

http://www.time.com/time/specials/2007/article/0,28804,1725112_1726934_1726935,00.html



http://freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/01/29/a-hannah-montana-concert-as-seen-through-the-eyes-of-an-economist/

9 comments:

Lydia said...

sorry, that second link i just thought was kind of interesting. it's an economists quest for rationality in hannah montana world.

Anonymous said...

it seems like so many of the economic situations we've talked over in class rely on people acting rationally. this list just proves that rational thought may be too hard to come by for those theoretical circumstances to ever occur.

Lyndsay Gavin said...

wow, I find this very interesting, and, as you said, a little sad. Our decisions are made based on so many factors that are not at all related to the choices we make. We make economic as well as political decisions based on media, and whatever our favorite celebs say. These people should not be made our most influential.

martywiese said...

Well, Britney's up to #2 now. Can you say w00t?

Lydia presented a good point about these stars influencing what we buy, watch, etc., but I'm wondering if this list is really accurate...

People seem to be voting almost based on a popularity contest. Yes, the stars who are winning out over our world's leaders are rich and can do important (or at least stupid and noticeable) things. On the other hand, I don't base as many economic decisions on who is promoting the best fashions of the season as I base decisions on the price of gas. Think of how many other purchases and activities are forgone due to the ever-rising price of gas (especially for teenagers).

Right now, I'm more influenced by the members of big oil companies and the president who is allowing our billion (or is it trillion now?) dollar war to continue. Unfortunately. :(

Brent said...

First of all, Marty, if I remember correctly the tab on the Iraq war exceeded 18 trillion according to Vanity Fair (It's on the cover and my mom subscribes to it). Haha, but there was a cool article about the new Indiana Jones movie a couple issues back, but that's all I read. Anyways, this is definitely a popularity contest and probably always will be. If it wasn't, Ralph Nader would've been president by now. It is very sad that Oprah can make best sellers out of books just by putting them on her show. Like Melody said, this is why the stuff we learn in econ can't ever interpret societies actions as this goes against rational thinking. It is just how our crazy world seems to work.

fileben said...

I think marty said it pretty well. people voted these celebrities not because will smith actually influences their choices, but because he's popularly seen on T.V. The actual influencers (oil producers, etc.) aren't often seen, and therefore not voted for. I guess what I'm saying is that this list isn't really accurate in terms of influencing economic decisions. I do think, however, that our pop culture influences the american moral lifestyle way more than we give it credit for.

Also, Brent, where'd you come up with that tab? Last I checked, the running cost was at $550 billion, and Joseph Stiglitz (Nobel Prize-winning economist) estimates the total at 3 to 5 trillion.

belzmat said...

I acutally was watching tv and people were comparing young Miley to the next Britney. But anyhoo I think it is a pitty that people find Hannah Montana more influencial than the president or 2possible prez. candidates, people will go out and buy to support say britney spears with her albums or t-shirt, perfume rather than put money into helping a person who can make a difference in our economy problems

BethanyStoppel said...

Wow, I hate Hannah Montana!!! But that's not the important thing. It does make sense that the "most popular" people are those that are targetted at pre-teens. Hannah Montana is plastered all of Disney and is used as an advertising goldmine. I was actually watching something the other day that was discussing if Britney's good behavior has aided the recession. Since she's not acting crazy anymore people arn't buying the rag-mags to see what she's up to. It's amazing, in a society of some many educated individuals that the ones we care most about are the ones that don't have any education.

JoelleBender said...

Wow. This is just pathetic. I despise Hannah Montana with a deep heartfelt passion.

I do understand, though, how these (somewhat untalented) "artists" can influence the economy. At work I've seen customers spend over $40 on tabloids, which run from $1.95 - $3.99, plus tax. I admit that I do, when it's really slow and I'm tremendously bored, read the tabloids at work, but I would never waste my money on them. This is the same thing as the whole debate over whether or not Obama would have been as successful without Oprah.